I'd update the HN submission url to the actual source, i.e. either the above game url, or its "how to play" section at https://pell.achromath.com/how-to-play .
Currently the submission points to a third party review of the game - IMO it seems more appropriate as a comment.
andersmurphy 1 days ago [-]
Wait. So if I write a review/article about a product the HN link should be changed to point to the product not my review? That makes no sense.
thih9 1 days ago [-]
If the review is about a casual web game and if instead of reading quotes, your impression and your ads I can experience the game myself then yes we should point to the product.
trizoza 1 days ago [-]
What ads are you talking about? There are 0 ads on my site!
thih9 1 days ago [-]
House ads do count.
trizoza 1 days ago [-]
You mean, links to other pages on my site?
thih9 16 hours ago [-]
When they are off topic, yes.
Note that the whole review seems off topic too. It’s neither more interesting nor more accessible than the topic itself.
trizoza 6 hours ago [-]
Dude, the links in that article go to:
1. The review framework used to review the game
2. The game page itself where user can post their own reviews 3. The original game url
Huge fan of this collection. Would love to collab if anyone knows more C than me (which means any C).
fph 1 days ago [-]
Why do incomplete paths light up the corresponding number? I don't understand this UI choice.
bsammon 1 days ago [-]
I submitted this gripe (before I saw your comment) to the "report an issue" widget on the puzzle site. I wonder if this puzzle will get ongoing development.
I have a few ideas for feature requests, but I'm not going to bother submitting them if it appears there's no interest.
achromath 1 days ago [-]
I'm the creator, got your request and made myself an issue to remember. Thanks for playing, and I'd love to hear what else you have in mind.
achromath 1 days ago [-]
Very fair point I will fix shortly.
trizoza 1 days ago [-]
Author here, can someone explain what happened here? I submitted this article 2 days ago and 1 upvote and it got some how resubmitted today?
I'd update the HN submission url to the actual source, i.e. either the above game url, or its "how to play" section at https://pell.achromath.com/how-to-play .
Currently the submission points to a third party review of the game - IMO it seems more appropriate as a comment.
Note that the whole review seems off topic too. It’s neither more interesting nor more accessible than the topic itself.
I can't see how are these off topic?
I have a few ideas for feature requests, but I'm not going to bother submitting them if it appears there's no interest.
https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=26998308